Buy a Fixer-Upper or New Construction Home: What’s the Best Decision?

Frame the decisions in your mind when you decide "Should I buy a new construction home or renovate an existing home?"

So, you’ve recently decided to buy a home. First of all—congratulations! We know you’ve been working hard to pay down your credit cards, boost your credit score, and scrape together a modest down payment in the process. Your hard work is paying off!

Buying a home can be a time consuming, complicated process. With the right agent by your side, much of that stress can be mitigated or avoided altogether. However, a good agent can only take you so far if you’re not clear on your goals and needs.

It’s time to determine the priorities of your dream home, from choosing the best neighborhood to the right number of bathrooms. As you do so, consider one important question that will guide the course of your home search: Should I buy a new construction home or renovate an existing (possibly older) fixer-upper?

Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of each purchase:

New Construction Homes


Move-in Ready – Obviously, newly built homes don’t require you to pull up old carpet or repaint the walls before you move in. If you’re looking for the quickest path to being settled in a home of your own, new homes are the best bet.

Floor Plan – If you invest in a custom-built home, you are sure to get a floor plan that matches your lifestyle—because you get to pick the design. If you work with the architect early in the construction, you may even be able to pick custom finishes.

Energy Efficiency – New homes are held to higher insulation and efficiency standards than older homes that are being resold. New homes also tend to have newer appliances. Quality windows and an efficient washer will equal significant savings over time.

Maintenance – In addition to needing less work (or no work) up front, new homes will require less maintenance over the first few years of your ownership. You’re less likely to run into unexpected expenses, like needing to replace septic tanks or damaged gutters.

Amenities – Looking for a neighborhood with an active lifestyle? New homes in planned communities often include access to community amenities, like clubhouses, recreational facilities, community spaces, and trails.


Additional Upfront Costs – All the best benefits of new homes (quality construction, new appliances, community pool, etc.) mean your purchase price will be more expensive. Consider HOA costs and property taxes as you look for the right community for you.

Less-than-Ideal Location – Your community itself may be walkable, but that doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll be close to work, groceries, or other frequented locations. Factor in the cost of your commute to your projected monthly expenses.

The Cost of Land – Even if your construction costs are reasonable, don’t forget to consider the value of the land the home is on. Planned communities often have larger lot sizes, which can add up quickly.

Immature Landscaping – Will you have to invest in heavier curtains to deter nosey neighbors because there isn’t a single full-grown tree in the neighborhood? If outdoor home features are just as important to you as indoor features, that may cost you extra at a new home.

The Wait – It can be fun to sit down with builders to pick out your ideal floor plan and molding style. But consider construction time (and possible delays) that come with a custom home. A six-month wait is normal if you’re building from the ground up.

Fixer-Upper Homes


More House for the Money – All the space may not be immediately livable, but fixer-uppers have a lower price per square foot than newly built homes. If you’re searching for a space you can grow into, a fixer-upper may be what you seek.

Charm and Location – Older homes tend to be in older neighborhoods and more urban settings. In addition to inside charms (like crown molding or original tiling), they could also offer a lot of neighborhood charm.

Shorter CommutesOlder neighborhoods and urban settings are also more likely to be closer to city centers. If you like to walk to restaurants, grocery stores, or even to work, this could be a cost-effective opportunity to cut down your commute.

Property Tax Rates – Fixer-uppers in less affluent communities will not accrue increases in property taxes at the same rate as new homes in fancy neighborhoods. Even with the cost of significant home renovations, this could keep your costs low over time.

Long-term Projects – Some people love homes that evolve as they do. Pick a fixer-upper if you don’t mind long-term renovations and want the opportunity to get really creative with your space.


Outdated Features and Appliances – Will you have to replace all the knob-and-tube wiring and lead-based paint in your funky historic home? Will the home need to be checked for asbestos? How old is that refrigerator, anyway? Older homes require you to ask more questions up front to gauge renovations that go beyond pure aesthetics.

Unexpected Problems and “Invisible Repairs” – Older homes require more upkeep, even as you continue to renovate. Ask questions even about features that are currently in good shape, perhaps roofs and plumbing, to determine their ages. This can give you an idea of what will require work down the line and when.

Investments that Don’t Equal Increased Value – Some home improvements add more to the resale value of your home than others. Be careful to weigh what needs done to make the home livable versus the fun (read: expensive) upgrades you may not be able to recoup when you move.

Long-term Construction Zone – Unless you’re a professional flipper, it can be hard to own a home that requires a lot of work. You may not have the opportunity to focus on your home full time. And who wants to live in a construction zone for possibly years?

Your Timing – Experts recommend that you should plan on living in homes that require extensive renovations for 7–10 years before you are able to recoup the costs. If you can’t see yourself living in the space for that long, perhaps it’s not the best investment for you.

So, What’s the Better Decision?: Buying a Fixer-Upper or New Construction Home

There are no cut-and-dry answers to the question of whether an old or a new home is a better buy. As you saw above, your decision will be unique to your personal goals, your financial capabilities, and your aptitude for renovation and design. The activity of the particular community in which you want to live will also affect your decision. 

Are you ready to discuss your options with your Allen Tate/Beverly-Hanks real estate agent? Your agent will be happy to help steer you toward the right purchase for you. Contact an Allen Tate/Beverly-Hanks real estate agent today!

All real estate is local. In order to make confident real estate decisions, it’s important to have timely and neighborhood-specific information. Contact us today to speak with an Allen Tate/Beverly-Hanks real estate agent about buying homes and land in Western North Carolina. View all Allen Tate/Beverly-Hanks real estate listings.

12 Responses to “Buy a Fixer-Upper or New Construction Home: What’s the Best Decision?”

  1. My husband and I are planning on building our dream home. I like the advice about how a newly constructed home will allow you to get the floor plan that you want. Another benefit of a newly constructed home is that it will be up to date on all codes and have better electrical services.

  2. Many of my clients who can’t afford to buy new construction buy a dilapidated or a home very small in an area they choose (most times with more land) demolish the existing structure or add on additional sq ft or build brand new construction for the FHA required down payment of 3.5%. The pgm allows borrowers to include all fees in the budget such as demolition, architectural specs & plans, permits, inspection fees, draws etc.. just like custom new construction. The catch is the previous structure must have been issued a COO letter at some point & the new construction must be built on the existing foundation. Can even move the foundation to another spot on the land or to another piece of land in the state. Can also gut & leave the frame if built with good bones to save more money. Custom Builder chosen must be licensed & insured & have done like projects within 12 months. It’s an excellent renovation loans that most Agents that many are afraid of don’t know half of what it offers. I originate both FHA & Fannie Conventional renovations loans in GA, AL, FL, NC & SC purchase & refinance. Please refer any consumers & agents in my states that may need an experienced professional to educate them & close their loan project very timely! I’ve been doing this a long time & extremely passionate out it. It’s the only job I’d do for Free if I could afford to. I’m on FB & LinkedIn. Thanks Patrice

  3. A lot of real estate investor get turned off once they take a first glance at a certain property and see that it is a fixer-upper home and dare not take a second look. Let me tell you this straight up, DO NOT JUDGE A PROPERTY BY IT’S LOOKS! Real estate investment properties come in many different forms which is why you should not be turned off by the looks of a home but rather pay further attention to the details.

  4. I like what you said about how you can pick the design of the floor plan so it matches your lifestyle. I like to encourage my kids to play with each other when they finish their homework, but I like to keep an eye on them just in case. It’s hard to do in our current house because the design is pretty closed-off. Maybe my husband and I should talk to a new home builder about building a house that’s open so my family can spend more time together.

  5. I’m glad you pointed out that if you want a home that’s move-in ready, you should probably go with a new home since it will be the fastest and most convenient way to move into a home. My husband and I want to move closer to his work to shorten his commute, so we’ve been trying to decide between a new home subdivision or an older home. I want the moving process to be over as quickly as possible, so it sounds like a new home will be the best choice for us!

  6. My husband and I both received full-time job offers in the same city, so we are prepared to buy our first home and settle down! We are thinking about getting a new construction home but don’t know much about it, so this article was very helpful. Thanks for explaining that a new construction home will allow us to pick a custom floor plan that matches our needs.

  7. I love the idea of buying a home to fix it up so you don’t have to sacrifice anything but time. My sister though likes the idea of building from scratch but she’s been thinking bout trying to build a lot of it herself. We’ve been looking into finding a place that can put up the scaffolding that she can use to get where she needs to on the house with less danger.

End of blog post Beverly-Hanks logo


Back to News

Leave a Reply